Encore vs Encore ESP
Coffee · 1,755 owner opinions across both productsBuy the Encore.
Reddit's answer is the Baratza Encore. Buy only if you prioritize repairability and value and don't mind a DIY fix if the burr holder goes. The Encore ESP is a Stay Away — don’t buy it — get the Niche Zero instead. Both sit within $10 of each other today.
Built from 1,755 owner opinions across both products · 236 long-term reports · how we decide
Owners who used both
Not two separate populations — 55 people whose comments show they used, returned, or directly compared both. This is the same person choosing.
1 said it depends on the use case.
The corpus favors the Encore by 22 points, but people who used both chose the Encore ESP 35–19. Different populations, honestly reported.
What owners say
67% would buy againof 1,598 owners
First 6 months 46% → long-term 79%+33of 225 long-term owners
45% would buy againof 157 owners
First 6 months 31% → long-term 54%+23of 11 long-term owners
The Encore's record runs 1,598 owners against 157 for the Encore ESP — weigh the thinner side accordingly.
What you’ll regret
The burr holder
~1 in 4 long-term reports mention a failure, most commonly the burr holder, with onset typically between 3 and 25 months. Of those reports, 56 describe the issue as resolved under warranty versus 40 that landed outside it — lean toward resolved, but not decisively. The serious-failure rate of 18% sits slightly above the 14% baseline for the 6 coffee grinders we track, making it a touch less reliable than the category average.
Typically reported months 3–24 · 225 long-term owners
No single component dominates
~1 in 2 long-term reports mention a failure — the highest failure rate of the 6 coffee grinders we track, and well above the category baseline of 14%. Most components implicated involve the burr assembly and associated fittings (quick-release knob, burr holder, burr ring, burr shaft). Onset typically falls between 2 and 5 years of use, which is longer than the category median of 7 months before first failure. Warranty outcomes lean slightly toward resolved, but with 12 resolved cases against 8 unresolved, a meaningful share lands outside coverage.
Typically reported months 2–4 · 11 long-term owners
These are the share of long-term owner reports that mention a failure, not the share of units that fail — owners with working units mostly don’t post.
Price and value
$199
Price links carry an affiliate tag. It never changes the verdict.
repairability and long-term value over pristine grind consistency from day one.
strong support culture and broad grind-range versatility matter more than long-term mechanical reliability.
Long-term durability is your first priority — both carry a real failure record, and the MiiCoffee DF54 (70% would buy again, $207.96) does not.
Questions people ask about this matchup
Which is better, the Encore or the Encore ESP?
Reddit's answer is the Baratza Encore. Buy only if you prioritize repairability and value and don't mind a DIY fix if the burr holder goes. The Encore ESP is a Stay Away — don’t buy it — get the Niche Zero instead.
Which is more reliable, the Encore or the Encore ESP?
The Encore, by the numbers: 18% of its long-term reports mention a serious failure against 36% for the Encore ESP.
Encore full verdict →Encore ESP full verdict →All Coffee verdicts →