shouldibuythat
← All verdicts

Encore ESP

Baratza · Coffee · 77 threads · 21 long-term reports · re-checked Oct 27, 2026 · how we decide →
Stay Awaydivisive among owners
46%of 279 owners recommend it
Zero72%
Category average68%
Encore ESP46%
#5 of 6 coffee grinders we track
45% of reports < 12 months old
~1 in 2 burr holder failures
Evidence: Moderate279 owner opinions · 21 long-term · owners disagree sharply
Price
$199

Don’t buy it — get the DF54 instead

High failure rate and a recommend score well below the category average make this a hard sell — consider the DF54 first.

Stronger buy if you value

responsive customer support and wide grind-range versatility across espresso and filter styles.

Weaker buy if you value

long-term durability — ~1 in 2 long-term owner reports describe a failure, the worst rate of the 6 coffee grinders we track.

What the 357 mentions are about

grouped into themes · share of opinionated mentions
customer_support · 23
durability · 20
reliability · 16
versatility · 14
reliability · 12
CUSTOMER_SUPPORTBaratza's support team comes up repeatedly — some owners report replacement parts shipped quickly and without hassle.
VERSATILITYA vocal minority values its ability to dial in both espresso and filter brews from one machine.
RELIABILITYSome owners report years of trouble-free use, citing consistent grind output over time.
DURABILITYA vocal minority flags plastic component failures — burr holders and carriers are the most cited parts.
RELIABILITYA vocal minority reports grind consistency degrading, often tied to the same burr assembly failures.
RETENTIONSome owners report difficulty retaining ground coffee, with the chute and discharge disc cited.
RELIABILITY~1 in 2 report the burr holder failing, months 2–6 — usually made right under warranty.

The failure mode

~1 in 2

~1 in 2 long-term owner reports describe a failure — the highest failure rate of the 6 coffee grinders we track, against a category baseline of 14%. The burr holder is the most cited component, with onset typically between 2 and 7 months. Warranty outcomes lean resolved, meaning most cases were made right under warranty, though 13 unresolved cases were also reported.

43% report a serious failure. Typical for coffee: ~14%. Fails more than most of its category.

Most common concern: A vocal minority flags plastic component failures — burr holders and carriers are the most cited parts.

Based on observed owner reports, not a sampled failure rate. ~1 in 2 of the long-term owner reports we analysed mention a failure — not the same as ~1 in 2 of units failing.

How sentiment ages

The honeymoon

Early ownership sentiment is low at 26%, with many buyers still calibrating and encountering initial setup friction.

A year of ownership

Long-term sentiment climbs to 54% — the tone strengthens considerably for owners who avoid or work through the failure pattern.

Pricing

$199Street
No live retailer offers tracked yet — figures are the street price and MSRP we have on record.

Buy this instead if…

DF54 — you want a coffee grinder with a less severe failure pattern reported by long-term owners.

See its verdict →
We’ll tell you if Reddit changes its mind.

Verdicts re-weigh with every crawl — if this one moves tiers, watchers hear first.

How it compares in Coffee

See all Coffee verdicts →

Questions people keep asking

Is the Baratza Encore ESP worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Stay Away. Don’t buy it — get the DF54 instead. High failure rate and a recommend score well below the category average make this a hard sell — consider the DF54 first.

What is the most common complaint about the Encore ESP?

A vocal minority flags plastic component failures — burr holders and carriers are the most cited parts. The recurring failure shows up in about 1 in 2 long-term owners: ~1 in 2 long-term owner reports describe a failure — the highest failure rate of the 6 coffee grinders we track, against a category baseline of 14%. The burr holder is the most cited component, with onset typically between 2 and 7 months. Warranty outcomes lean resolved, meaning most cases were made right under warranty, though 13 unresolved cases were also reported.

What should I buy instead of the Encore ESP?

Reddit's usual alternative is the DF54 — if you want a coffee grinder with a less severe failure pattern reported by long-term owners.