shouldibuythat
← All Coffee verdicts
Coffee · head to head

Encore ESP vs DF54

Reddit's answer is the MiiCoffee DF54. Buy it if you value consistent grind quality and a grinder that owners stick with long-term. The Encore ESP is a Risky Buy — buy only if you value repairability and strong value, and don't mind the occasional fix-it session.

Worth knowingOwners of the Encore ESP most often point to the DF54.
Baratza Encore ESP
Baratza · Coffee

Encore ESP

Risky Buy$199.95
67% of 1,326 owners recommend
~1 in 4 failure rate — Reliability here is harder to pin down than it looks: ~1 in 4 is our computed figure, but with too few long-term owners reporting back, that rate is not yet reliable. Isolated failure reports do exist — the burr holder leads with 23 reports, followed by the ring burr holder (16) and the motor (9). Onset typically falls between 3 and 25 months. Warranty outcomes split evenly: roughly half of reported failures were resolved under warranty, half landed outside it. The Encore ranks last for reliability among the 6 coffee grinders we track, with a serious-failure rate of 18% against a category baseline of 5%.

Buy only if you value repairability and strong value, and don't mind the occasional fix-it session.

+ The most cited strength: owners fix it themselves, and Baratza sells every part you need.

− A vocal minority describe plastic parts — especially the burr holder — breaking within a few years.

Full verdict →
MiiCoffee DF54
MiiCoffee · Coffee

DF54

Buy If$229
71% of 686 owners recommend
~1 in 13 failure rate — ~1 in 13 long-term reports mention a failure, but reliability is not fully measurable here — the long-term owner pool is too small to confirm that rate. Isolated reports name the chute and clogging-related components most often, with onset typically within the first 4 months. Warranty outcomes lean unresolved, so don't count on a straightforward fix if something goes wrong early.

Buy it if you value consistent grind quality and a grinder that owners stick with long-term.

+ Repeatedly mentioned as a grinder owners trust and keep — the single most cited praise cluster.

− Clogging — chute, declumper, and grind path — is a recurring complaint that dominates reliability threads.

Full verdict →

Questions people keep asking

Which is better, the Encore ESP or the DF54?

Reddit's answer is the MiiCoffee DF54. Buy it if you value consistent grind quality and a grinder that owners stick with long-term. The Encore ESP is a Risky Buy — buy only if you value repairability and strong value, and don't mind the occasional fix-it session.

Is the Baratza Encore ESP worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Risky Buy. Buy only if you value repairability and strong value, and don't mind the occasional fix-it session. Loves to be fixed, needs to be — the Encore earns its fans through repairability, not flawless hardware.

Is the MiiCoffee DF54 worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Buy If. Buy it if you value consistent grind quality and a grinder that owners stick with long-term. Strong grind quality and a loyal following, but clogging is a recurring complaint you should know about before buying.