shouldibuythat
← All Coffee verdicts
Coffee · head to head

Encore ESP vs Classic Pro

Reddit's answer is the Gaggia Classic Pro. Buy it — if you want a durable machine that holds its value and rewards the time spent learning it. The Encore ESP is a Risky Buy — buy only if you value repairability and see fixing a plastic burr holder as part of the ownership deal.

Baratza Encore ESP
Baratza · Coffee

Encore ESP

Risky Buy$199.95
66% of 1,343 owners recommend
~1 in 4 failure rate — ~1 in 4 long-term owner reports describe a failure, most involving the burr holder or burr ring assembly, typically between 3 and 25 months of use. That is the highest failure rate of the 6 coffee grinders we track — well above the category baseline of 5%. Warranty outcomes are split: roughly half of reported cases were resolved under warranty, but a meaningful share landed outside it.

Buy only if you value repairability and see fixing a plastic burr holder as part of the ownership deal.

+ Parts are cheap and widely available; owners report grinding for years after replacing the plastic burr holder.

− Durability is a recurring concern; the plastic burr holder is the single most-cited failure component.

Full verdict →
Gaggia Classic Pro
Gaggia · Coffee

Classic Pro

Strong Buy$549
77% of 1,034 owners recommend
~1 in 15 failure rate — ~1 in 15 long-term reports mention a failure, spread across components including the boiler (3 reports), pump (2), and solenoid valve (2), with onset anywhere from 4 to 61 months. Warranty coverage leaned unresolved — most failures landed outside warranty.

Buy it — if you want a durable machine that holds its value and rewards the time spent learning it.

+ Owners regularly cite it as a machine built to last; durability is the single most cited strength.

− A recurring complaint: the machine has a steep learning curve that frustrates newcomers.

Full verdict →

Questions people keep asking

Which is better, the Encore ESP or the Classic Pro?

Reddit's answer is the Gaggia Classic Pro. Buy it — if you want a durable machine that holds its value and rewards the time spent learning it. The Encore ESP is a Risky Buy — buy only if you value repairability and see fixing a plastic burr holder as part of the ownership deal.

Is the Baratza Encore ESP worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Risky Buy. Buy only if you value repairability and see fixing a plastic burr holder as part of the ownership deal. A repairable entry-level grinder with a real failure pattern — good if you're willing to wrench on it, not if you want it to just work.

Is the Gaggia Classic Pro worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Strong Buy. Buy it — if you want a durable machine that holds its value and rewards the time spent learning it. The most-recommended espresso machine of the 3 we track, and the one with the lowest failure rate — but it demands patience to dial in.