shouldibuythat
← All Audio verdicts
Audio · head to head

AirPods Max vs WH-1000XM5

Reddit rates both Stay Away. The split is what you want: the AirPods Max — don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead. The WH-1000XM5 — don’t buy it — get the Sony WH-1000XM4 instead.

Apple AirPods Max
Apple · Audio

AirPods Max

Stay Away$397.67
40% of 2,158 owners recommend
~1 in 2 failure rate — ~1 in 2 long-term owner reports describe a failure — the highest failure rate of the 10 wireless headphones we track, against a category baseline of 27%. Connectivity is the most cited component, followed by battery and moisture/condensation damage. Failures typically surface between 12 and 31 months of ownership. Of tracked warranty outcomes, 111 cases landed unresolved versus 66 resolved — so failures usually land outside warranty or go unmade-right.

Don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead

+ Repeatedly mentioned as the reference point other headphones get measured against.

− A vocal minority flags the price as hard to justify given the reliability record.

Full verdict →
Sony WH-1000XM5
Sony · Audio

WH-1000XM5

Stay Away$248
39% of 2,433 owners recommend
~1 in 3 failure rate — ~1 in 3 long-term owner reports describe a failure, overwhelmingly the hinge (132 counts), typically surfacing between 5 and 23 months. Warranty resolution skews unresolved: 93 unresolved versus 36 resolved cases. At 30% serious-failure rate, this is above the 27% baseline for the 10 wireless headphones we track — failing more than most in its category.

Don’t buy it — get the Sony WH-1000XM4 instead

+ Repeatedly mentioned as the benchmark other wireless headphones get compared against.

− A recurring theme: hinge failures dominate long-term reports, with 132 hinge-specific counts logged.

Full verdict →

Questions people keep asking

Which is better, the AirPods Max or the WH-1000XM5?

Reddit rates both Stay Away. The split is what you want: the AirPods Max — don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead. The WH-1000XM5 — don’t buy it — get the Sony WH-1000XM4 instead.

Is the Apple AirPods Max worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Stay Away. Don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead. Exceptional sound and ANC — but ~1 in 2 long-term reports describe a failure, and only 40% of owners would buy again.

Is the Sony WH-1000XM5 worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Stay Away. Don’t buy it — get the Sony WH-1000XM4 instead. Exceptional sound with a structural flaw you must factor in: ~1 in 3 long-term reports describe a hinge failure.