shouldibuythat
← All Audio verdicts
Audio · head to head

AirPods Max vs AirPods Pro 2

Reddit's answer is the Apple AirPods Pro 2. Buy only if you value sound quality and noise cancellation and are deep in the Apple ecosystem. The AirPods Max is a Stay Away — don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead.

Apple AirPods Max
Apple · Audio

AirPods Max

Stay Away$397.67
40% of 2,158 owners recommend
~1 in 2 failure rate — ~1 in 2 long-term owner reports describe a failure — the highest failure rate of the 10 wireless headphones we track, against a category baseline of 27%. Connectivity is the most cited component, followed by battery and moisture/condensation damage. Failures typically surface between 12 and 31 months of ownership. Of tracked warranty outcomes, 111 cases landed unresolved versus 66 resolved — so failures usually land outside warranty or go unmade-right.

Don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead

+ Repeatedly mentioned as the reference point other headphones get measured against.

− A vocal minority flags the price as hard to justify given the reliability record.

Full verdict →
Apple AirPods Pro 2
Apple · Audio

AirPods Pro 2

Risky Buy$225
50% of 1,265 owners recommend
~1 in 4 failure rate — ~1 in 4 long-term reports mention a failure, typically appearing within the first 11 months. Components span microphone, transparency mode, the case, and connectivity. Warranty outcomes lean slightly unresolved (39 unresolved vs. 33 resolved), so coverage is not a sure safety net. At rank 2 of 4 wireless earbuds we track for failure rate, this sits above the category midpoint — not the worst, but elevated enough to notice. Failures do arrive faster than the category baseline onset of 5 months suggests is typical.

Buy only if you value sound quality and noise cancellation and are deep in the Apple ecosystem.

+ Repeatedly mentioned as a reference point other earbuds get compared against.

− A vocal minority find ANC inconsistent or degraded, especially after firmware updates.

Full verdict →

Questions people keep asking

Which is better, the AirPods Max or the AirPods Pro 2?

Reddit's answer is the Apple AirPods Pro 2. Buy only if you value sound quality and noise cancellation and are deep in the Apple ecosystem. The AirPods Max is a Stay Away — don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead.

Is the Apple AirPods Max worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Stay Away. Don’t buy it — get the Sony XM4 instead. Exceptional sound and ANC — but ~1 in 2 long-term reports describe a failure, and only 40% of owners would buy again.

Is the Apple AirPods Pro 2 worth it?

Reddit's verdict is Risky Buy. Buy only if you value sound quality and noise cancellation and are deep in the Apple ecosystem. The most-recommended wireless earbuds we track, but ~1 in 4 long-term reports describe a failure — strong buy for Apple loyalists who accept that trade-off.